4.5 The Best Error You Can Make: Brent Hayes Edwards and Jean-Baptiste Naudy on Claude McKay (SW)

What can a French translator do with a novelist who writes brilliantly about the “confrontation between Englishes?” How can such a confrontation be made legible across the boundaries of language, nation, and history? Renowned scholar and translator Brent Hayes Edwards sits down with publisher and translator Jean-Baptiste Naudy to consider these questions in a wide-ranging discussion about translating the Jamaican American writer Claude McKay. They focus especially on the recent translation into French of McKay’s 1941 Amiable with Big Teeth, which paints a satirical portrait of efforts by 1930s Harlem intelligentsia to organize support for the liberation of fascist-controlled Ethiopia. Brent and Jean-Baptiste consider McKay’s lasting legacy and ongoing revival in the U.S. and France. Translating McKay into French, they note, is a matter of reckoning with France’s own imperial history. That history, along with McKay’s complex understanding of race both in the U.S. and abroad, is illuminated in this conversation about one of the Harlem Renaissance’s most celebrated writers. Be sure to check out this episode’s special bonus material for a dramatic, bilingual reading from Amiable with Big Teeth by Jean-Baptiste!

Mentioned in this episode:

Amiable with Big Teeth, Claude McKay (1941)
Les Brebis Noirs de Dieu, Claude McKay, Trans. Jean-Baptiste Naudy (2021)
The Practice of Diaspora, Brent Edwards Hayes (2003)
A Long Way from Home, Claude McKay (1937)
The Price of the Ticket: Collected Nonfiction 1948-1985, James Baldwin (1985)
Banjo, Claude McKay (1929)
Home to Harlem, Claude McKay (1928)
Romance in Marseille, Claude McKay (1929)
The Souls of Black Folk, W.E.B. Du Bois’s (1903)
Their Eyes Were Watching God, Zora Neale Hurston (1937)
Mais leurs yeux dardaient sur Dieu, Zora Neale Hurston, Trans. Sika Fakambi
Passing, Nella Larsen (1929)
Quicksand, Nella Larsen (1928)
Cane, Jean Toomer (1923)
Quartier Noir, Claude McKay, Trans. Louis Guilloux (1932)
Dictionary of Untranslatables, Ed. Barbara Cassin et al. (2014)
Phantom Africa, Michel Leiris, Trans. Brent Hayes Edwards (2017)
The Wretched of the Earth, Frantz Fanon (1961)

Listen and read:

Audio: The Best Error You Can Make

Transcript: 4.5 The Best Error You Can Make

10.4 Place Presents Itself To You in Fragments: Ivan Vladislavić and Jeanne-Marie Jackson (MAT) Novel Dialogue

How to write about place is a question that cuts across the career of the South African Ivan Vladislavić. The questions of place and space are pressing ones in the context of South Africa, where the transition to democracy in 1994 included a redrawing of the national map, and the last three decades have seen the large-scale transformation of urban centers such as Johannesburg. What defines Johannesburg a literary city? asks the critic Jeanne-Marie Jackson. From this unfurls a series of reflections about the writer’s relationship to place and the various ways in which narrative form can be bent to capture the experience of place—and in particular the experience of a place as it changes across time. The resulting work may feel fragmentary, Ivan allows, but that is a function of the nature of place rather than an imposition on the part of the writer. Finally, the conversation turns toward Ivan’s choice to study Afrikaans literature in the 1970s. As a tradition often at odds with Afrikaner politics and urgently concerned with the world Ivan himself inhabited, reading the work of Afrikaans writers such as Ingrid Winterbach, Entienne Leroux, André Brink, and Breyten Breytenbach offered a vital counterpoint to Ivan’s training in the English canon. Ivan closes by fondly remembering the teacher who introduced him to the writer’s notebook, a habit that continues to be crucial to his practice today. Mentioned in this episode: The Folly Double Negative The Near North Zoë Wicomb, You Can’t Get Lost in Cape Town Georges Pérec Gauteng John Miles, Ampie Coetzee, Ernst Lindenberg, and Taurus Publishers Marlene van Niekerk Nadine Gordimer The Goon Show Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
  1. 10.4 Place Presents Itself To You in Fragments: Ivan Vladislavić and Jeanne-Marie Jackson (MAT)
  2. 10.3 Just Slightly Outside the Circle: Peter Orner and Sarah Wasserman (EH)
  3. 10.2 Beautiful Sentences Matter. Billy-Ray Belcourt and Matt Hooley (SW)
  4. 10.1 "Extreme Circumstances, Extreme Reactions:” Aaron Gwyn and Sean McCann (JP)
  5. We Better Laugh About It: A Discussion with Álvaro Enrigue and Maia Gil’Adí